Your complete guide to Costco's Giant Blueberry Custard Pie Is Taking over Bakery Aisles for Under $20, covering expert perspectives.

Deciding which bulk dessert earns valuable refrigerator space requires looking at the numbers. The table below outlines how this seasonal summer dessert stacks up against the warehouse's other celebrated bakes in weight, cost, and party economics.

Bakery Item Retail Price Net Weight Cost Per Pound Estimated Servings
Blueberry Custard Pie $18.99, $19.99 ~3.6 lbs (58 oz) ~$5.27/lb 12, 16 slices
Key Lime Pie (Seasonal) $16.99 ~4.2 lbs (68 oz) ~$4.04/lb 14, 16 slices
Cheesecake with Fruit Topping $22.99 ~5.0 lbs (80 oz) ~$4.60/lb 16, 20 slices
Standard Apple Pie $14.99 ~4.5 lbs (72 oz) ~$3.33/lb 12, 16 slices